Wednesday, November 18, 2026

And the ABC reckon they are doing a good job

 News24's hosting of a forum last night led by Keiran Gilbert was a lesson in how to run a hall meeting well.

The ABC clearly suffer from wanting to be power brokers just like the major parties --but don't see their problem. 
They let Tony Jones and his mate run controlled theatre until the thing falls apart for everyone but the unthinking sycophants.  Unfortunately the ABC's brand of cynicism ( a sign of despair in reality )  is a depressing incentive all around ---including amongst young people . DISGRACEFUL   too comfortable too inexperienced and not used to going to confession.

Warren Pickering brought a breath of fresh air , We all just pray that the power doesn't get to his lot like it does to others. 
And that he and his fellows consult widely, Great to hear him say no policy on the run ! He will need help to answer questions well .Also .    

 
Also look here 
The only thing Ellen smashed was any suggestion her party has any wisdom about anything complex. Unfit to govern +the reason Labor now have no mandate + make no sense - all slogans

Thursday, November 12, 2026

God help us , the Narcissists in the West are everywhere

 God help us , the Narcissists in the West are everywhere  and worse -- in charge !
Boy, its hard at election time, to know who to vote for! 

And why is it  in November 2026, we have people like Trump who exudes the confidence, not of competence, but of a self made man. One whose focus has been for most of his life on himself, and how he can accumulate wealth for himself. We must be mad , or at least some of us. 
Perhaps, it's not all our leaders problem either but because we believe too much in the self made man ? 
You think of a few, I know some who should have left Parliament decades ago. And worse,  many of them never made anything but a story to get a seat. 












Maybe time to look in the mirror? 

Maybe we are all in need of a good look inside the system that's failing us in the West .
We absolutely must see it because other political machinery outside (especially other man is master faiths) us can see it.  


The ineffectiveness of the West in recent times 

One of the reasons why Western non believers are now worried is because they trust, not in God, but in government and the law. Such a faith doesn't work and even allows and denies moral choices.

In the case of the " many parties problem "( That the senate ticket allows suspect groups to stand) Getup has rightly identified the risk of abuse, but has no answer to its use because the abuse is due to personal stupidity ( Jung says the only problem is man) and not to do with the problem of technology; the many parties allegiance opportunity in Senate voting allows for diversity and recognises the corners where we touch base. The case for having something like it is sound - if the people were not so stupid and lazy thinking. 

For example . I won't vote Green first because the Green political movement is totally in its infancy, and no house should be run by children, and I want to insist that our children work in the public service professionally. The profession is being squashed and dumbed down simply because the Greens and other parties think they know how to do our work. The worst kind of boss we can have is one who thinks they know what they are doing. 
Here 's the paradox; I do like some of the Green's housing policies. I do believe in Parliament, not in mandates invented by parties. Labor leaders currently have only 30 +% of voters who would back them. Our current government have no mandates IMO  
Children maybe right about what we do wrong, but they are not helpful when the tough job of doing right comes along. http://dogood.blogspot.com

Tom Holland, the historian, is very helpfully talking about the confusion of the West at the moment. His book Dominion.

The rebels in the West are trying to do things with half-baked framing when the engine and the fuel for reform is denied.  Without it, he thinks post modernist reactionary doctrines will fail, Others who would take over our country and degree of suicidal empathy note the huge weakness and waste that the West cannot see.   

We also always only ever see through a glass dimly. When Pauline Hanson's Please Explain modifies her allegiances, she is only doing what we should all do. One reason One Nation party has appeal ( I agree that she will draw plenty of simpletons and racists but so do they all) is because she is leading , like @ABC Hard Quiz does with the full frontal. Plain speaking is not everything, but it is what we expect of parliamentary reps and unlike so many in hiding behind the loud party people, we at least know much of what she thinks, she is not prepared to be PM and she has changed her position -if only more did! ( that would mean the Parliament was working against ignorance arrogance and crass public opinion)  

We are IMO all compromised creatures with suspect allegiances and its amazing just how much Grace we live under. http://graceware.blogspot.com


Friday, October 16, 2026

Children in Charge

 Have you read Saad on Suicidal Empathy? Albo and his mates are

the perfect puppet innocents 4 those who think we should all be nice + things will work out fine or who think that "making a law against it " works






  1. Myers bill ( Digital Bill) to close a door on the internet when she hasn't got any idea of what elephants are already streaming around the room and through doors she will never explore.
  2. Labors mad alliance with the rest of the failed science class in proclaiming the evil of Carbon and their heavenly ambitions will make them the laughing stock of intellectual and scientific history.
  3. Albos mad loyalty in this last year with both Bowen and Burke will go down big and bad in history.  
  4. Carrolls alliance to win votes and pay women to kill children they don't like is the absolute pits.

Sunday, October 11, 2026

How can anyone vote for anyone in the coming election ?

 Do people thinking people in the West the worldwide have the same problem as us?
 Is Victoria the only place where only ego maniacs have stood up to solve our problems?
Is Victoria the only place where only ego maniacs are standing up to solve our problems?
Are we just all upset because thing are going from bad to worse?
Is the problem just as bad as it's always been, only we see it so clearly when a new party arrives and all the old ones look just like the bunch of old compromisers and incompetents they have been for eons?



I won't attempt to answer the above questions, but you might . Please havva go .

What I would say is

-- don't dismiss anyone on the basis of their party affiliations. Even those from One Nation  who are being carelessly condemned at by all the old argumentatives.
Yes IMO ON have huge policy challenges and why haven't they spent their time before the coming election sorting them out?   
Would they be dangerous in any new coalition ? I don't think they are going to control much in Victoria outright in December -- and could that be worse than the existing dreamers ? 

YOUR TASK  is seek to know all those who are standing and vote for the best of them ,
Very Scary 
Coalitions are fine as long as they are competent . And confession ability is good too and rare amongst the new pairs. 
The person you prefer to represent your community may not know what good policy looks like but neither do many of the existing compromised party hacks

USE your vote well in the Upper House well so the many quickfixers out there are scrutinized by people of maturity ( what the Senate means ) 

I could say more 
but not now . 

Thursday, October 01, 2026

Kick out the incompetent

 


A leader who is down to fixing potholes should leave. Any reasonable rep would have got the job done right first time. 

A leader who lets other pushy people tell him what to do is no leader.

Our current cringing bunch of fearmongers have let our roads go to pot because they have let their noisy friends worries about our use of chemicals cause them to stop us and them in our tracks .

Take the growing paranoia about glyphosate which Clarkson's farm has reminded the world will send us back into the dark ages because we can't grow enough food without  the right use of them. 

This growing fear and failure to launch its use on pavement edges has left pavements wetter and weaker, contributing to the potholes we all now dodge daily; A major reason for the failure of our roads is the grass that is allowed to grow next to the pavement.  

All readers can test glyphosate’s behaviour themselves by observing the yellow brown patched areas closely and see whether the product moves beyond the leaves it touches. Misuse of this quite specifically targeted growth link, or the more dangerous to water surfactants , by spraying before rain, or near waterways, should rightly be penalised.

Let’s, in  November, all choose planning competence over this fully fledged fear theatre that sits on the nest and waits for trouble to arrive.


Thursday, July 30, 2026

A Royal Commission will weed out our own rotten apples

 Premier Carroll has painted the perfect picture of a party in ruin ,
Only a bunch of innocents could come up with such rubbish.
 
Ben , the bright lad , thinks they need a royal commission to sort themselves out.
Clearly he , his party and his advisors,  have no idea of what evil is and how it works . 

How many weak and dull minds, without any idea of what evil is,( they worked with Andrews) are still sitting in the Victorian parliament trying 2 solve problems ( like sexism) that the children + mature adults outside understand much better than they do.

Poor old Jacinta was treated badly  according to Gillard 

It is not uncommon for those who tread where angels fear to tread in youth, ignorance and mere and simple oppressor prejudice to ignore the best and most powerful lessons of history ; that the greatest evil is done in the name of the best intention and that blaming  men and the current economic and legal structure is too simple. Ask  Greer or Ardnt. 

 As Brecht might have asked "how many chickens are still in the coupe still beating up the innocent ? "how many old crowers and weak men without any idea of what evil is  are still sitting in the Victorian parliament trying to solve problems the children outside understand much better than they do.

Sunday, June 28, 2026

ABC is again leading us where they want us to go

Our independent news service the ABC  is on a death wish ? 

Only yesterday the Sydney club of the ABC  are still getting fanatical in finding only the facts that suit a particular party view of what we need to know and believe.  

Half the news was about extreme weather events 

 ABC news from Sydney tonight featured  

--Photos of people swimming, and saying without  quoting exactly how  " hundreds of people have died during the current heat wave in Europe", If our servants for truth want to retain their jobs  they must quote a scientific specialist in such reports. 
The parliament must for the sake of our people and children insist in review and sackings within the ABC. 

-- The report on the recent filling of Lake Eyre is just a totally inadequate justification for the headline of " extreme weather "



Tuesday, June 23, 2026

New leaders all the time. Changing issues or just growing incompetence

 Starmer quits to yet another Staffer 

What is it ? they promise too much and therefore are weak popular puppets or are the people just fickle and unwilling to take the medicine?
Sky news guests suggest the situation is also driven by a reality check that Labor is impotent - just as One Nations growth is here is driven by a growing gap between talk and action.

UK commentators on that news channel mentioned are clear that even if the new leader knew what to do , he would be constrained, like the Victorian government will be in 2027, by huge debts of the dreamers making. http://thestockade.blogspot.com

Tuesday, June 09, 2026

Is our ABC on a suicidal mission too?

 
I am not one to dismiss the idea of a public broadcaster but as Gad Saad has said , the reactionaries in the West ( who still hang onto power in many places) have lost their way .
 The only thing they have kept from the robust and sustainable Christian Heritage  is an empty wishy washy understanding of love ( or something to offer the gods) -mere empathy. 
And of course mere empathy is not working ; its actually draining the life blood out of the West. 

Profile picture of John ModraMy letter to ABC Australia today 

About time you all accepted you are not accepted as independent and broad canvassing sources . You need much more than top changes ; a culture change that rids yourself of the failed science classes in particular . Otherwise it's just more arrogance ignorance, false reactionary and defensive fanaticism . You are dumbing down good science discussions and it is time you stopped it . 

Thursday, May 14, 2026

What's really behind the facade

 Pauline's party have historic win this weekend May 9th 2026   
I like the passion of many of the people involved, but as always, who in their associations is going to steer that to effective discipline of the ecological economy. All hands to better policy, but who is going to drive it and be convincing down the track? 
Hammer away good competents. 
We are in economic ruin and while the retreat from net zero will help free up the place from much waste, nothing can help us if we keep indulging in quick fix reaction to adverse pressures. (eg lack of good work and housing which can be addressed by good policy  

Hammer away good competents 
We went to air yesterday , not because I wanted to be political on our program of personal stories , but because One Nation has had a historic and largely unexpected win in the rural electorate of Farrer  alongside the northern edge of the Murray River.








Somehow, despite my doubts and fears about the general incompetence of those who go into Parliament,   I hope that the new personalities who are supporting One nation can break through the empty facades of the major parties.
When things are really crook as Brecht said , change comes in strange faces. 
Hanson Trump and Farage are indeed strange faces. 
And their popularity doesn't come from just the positivity and good intention in their passions, Infact all three seem to be reacting to our dissatisfaction with our way of life and the way it seems to be threatened by new migrants. Shallow reactions never solve anything. 
Those shallow reactionary drivers must make thinking people cautious because we want people to govern who can see past the shallow reactions of the desperate ( the well off majority ??) . 
 

We live in  strange times in the West where the dissatisfaction  we all feel ( especially with the real threat of higher prices for fuel in particular) seems to be transferred,  not to something positive directly but built up in  reaction to the huge incompetence and waste of the major parties ; parallels our indulgent waste of liquid fuels in particular. 
There is a lot of hypocrisy hidden away by my privileged generation. Some bad news is required before the good news it seems.  
Hammer away good competents.


My only reason for starting this blog and being on air is if we can get people who will listen closely to the ecological economy to improve the countries prospects for our children. 


The One Nation victory is clearly to do with having strong personal ambitions for good and  a strong sense that the personalities in the major parties have no hope . While it's very tempting to welcome the good intentions,  the real challenge is to make sure the ruling parties cut through the half truths that most facades demonstrate.  There are plenty of areas for genuine hope in our rich country . All new leaders must chase the competent 
Hammer away good competents. 

 

Saturday, February 28, 2026

Fathery figures

 

Howard the Father once steered like a pilot,

While Albo the Grandpa just lets the kids riot.

If a real Father came, would we sell him or buy him?

Too strong a medicine? — don’t vote for more lie in.





The key to this moment in Australia's history is probably uncertainty 
For the first time in a long time, we don't know what hope we can offer to our children 

Can we offer them?
A less economically divided society .....Rich oldies,  poorer young ...The lack of a real leader threat 
A means of keeping house  full time work creative work single income houses... cost of living threats
Creative work     The underemployment ...., lower wage take ....and ......migrants threats 
A means of keeping warm and moving around  ........High cost energy threats 
Economic futures confusion    Greenlabor offer limp jobs and trades in trees not careers in eco leadership   

Both major parties are in deep trouble because they cannot be convincing about their ability to deal with the above issues.
Who would trust those emerging parties who see the problems, but have no eco advisers for solutions 

More uncertainty threatens, just as it does right across the West .
Economy presses when a Ecological economic framing would greatly reduce the stresses.

The overly comfortable Libs are split but that's not all bad because there is within the conservatives who once found a home there an energy ( forget the many comfortable libs ) for 
stronger medicine and tougher parenting.   

 I just hope the Conservatives  take seriously that no leader can really work in such a rich but threatened ecosystem without taking advice - expert economic  and ecological economic advice.

The current incumbents talk about toughness ,but the reality is they offer only tokens ; costing us our assets and profits that could be used productively.... instead of being thrown to the wind . Green labor - so heavenly minded they are of little earthly use (always said of the overly religious) 


Some hope ?
The one enemy of our age we can deal with,  if we stop lying about, is poor parenting and throwing our savings into ineffective tokens


.  

Sunday, May 04, 2025

Albanese runs a team of too dull too easy

Just a brief reflection ( now that the election result is clear ) FOR all of those of us who, now this weekend , deeply grieve at the lost opportunities to build an Australia we are proud of.

I personally grieve that stupid blinkered guilt ridden, self centred and scientifically and otherwise ignorant Australians, as some of the most wealthy in the world, will continue to waste the opportunities they had to build and strengthen our children's future.

Visiting the people of eastern Europe over the last month has been very sobering for me for many reasons but in particular because, I can see not only in their current and long past land and work life struggles, the killing effects of an idealism that is only half baked . Australians as a whole at the moment, clearly can't.
Australians clearly cannot see that their governments huge investments in real world problem solving are tokenistic and temporary.
Perhaps thats what the rich have always done, but it doesn't make watching it happen in our free democracy easy.

I hate my generation for investing badly in guilt assuaging measures that do not, as Spain has shown this week, do anything to help us better manage our always limited resources.
Vigilance is always the key to true freedom and visiting Europe at this moment is a very sobering reminder of that of what we currently lack on our own island.

It's been my job to understand and care about what really works in resource management, but who really cares to build Australia as a place where careers and lives are built on the solid stuff of that!!!!

Wednesday, November 06, 2024

Republicans win -

 Why was the result such a surprise to those who like to think of themselves as" intellectual and progressives"; 
Are the people fickle and was the main reason the cost of living?
Yes but it's also about unconvincing chatter and scare campaigns by those who have NO Life experience and no practical science engagement to know why their biggest worry ( Global warming) changed to something that tries to take all ( Climate change ) means nothing but Ur saying nothing  - completely unprovable ( CO2 role in air temp )

Soon it will not be safe (scientifically) for anyone to safely talk about CO2 even though twits like Bowen and Greens may think they will. 

SUMMARY 
Because the comfortable elites (cheque in the mail every fortnight) have stopped listening and still run stupid and no longer relevant old Marxist prejudices and HYPOCRISY about whose rich and whose poor and why .

The right and left divide is the lefts myth that has been exploded TODAY .
The democrats and Leftists have nothing to say and their incompetence and distraction by the Greens and old rich class hate comes to the fore.  

Today's result in the USA is IMO a welcome victory for higher productivity and less sentimentality. A victory for hardworking people ( eg Regional )and less support for comfortable dependants . (eg Cities )
But such basic and responsible wins are hard to get because the ignorant idealists effectively hold power and force vote seeking nonsense TALK and PROMISES by big party leaders. ( eg less than 1% of population are farmers )
We in Australia need to note one reason why most Western Democracies are vulnerable to weird thinking idealism--- One vote one value seems fair . but makes popular chatter and the voice of the dependants the deciding factor.




Having said all that there is always a risk that poor and powerless will suffer if another rich group now get comfortable. We have some tough eco issues that require hard edges discomfort and real precision in decision. As a regional person who knows how much the public purse chasers get, I suggest anyone who gets a regular cheque ( incl from shares ) recognize who really are the poor. Time to rid ourselves of old prejudices about poor workers /unionists and the terrible nature of big business owners when they are shareholders with regular income . SOME MORE SOBER STUFF just in case you think I am far right , I am with SOLZ in saying that The West still does NOT YET have the courage and is too comfortable to properly look after its children. The Speech That Cost Solzhenitsyn Everything | Harvard Commencement Address 1978 (youtube.com) POSITIVES This new team will have the chance to not follow the idealists in their ignorant doctrines and scare campaigns that are anti science,

Monday, October 28, 2024

Danger of all dangers

Neitzsche said the danger of all dangers is that the herd mentality of those who cannot bring themselves to say what success is,  will continue to pull down those who do.

The public service and those who are dependent on them are nearly a majority
. 
Should we trust them? Are we getting a good return for all that taxing? 
Young people in Australia are , since 2008 ( when there was no Commonwealth debt )  bearing our debt to the tune of $15000 per person) , Hidden behind that growing lack of productivity are lack of careers in science.
What a terrible legacy we leave to our children.   

Do the Government need more things to fail in?  

The majority are not always right
and when civilization is under threat ( a complex matter of truth) the comfortable collective may not be willing to face why we got here and how and where we should move to .
The risk of the sheep jumping at shadows ( from all sides) is exacerbated in our era by screen addiction adding to the insecurity and mad jumping around of the desperate and dying old media machines. 
Our taxes are more than ever lost to last causes ( Something a range of thinking scientists and observers Above named Whitehead Ellul noted 


As an ecosystem resilience advisor, I have a lot to add to the completely unstable assertions about conservation imperatives from all sides , but such matters require precision and a willingness to listen , not to the many wannabes , but those competent to prosecute sustainability ONLY. Another time and place.    

Trump or no ? 
There are things I don't like about Trump but his team of supporters have competence on their side . The incumbents have only decades of incompetence driving them still.
The greatest evil is done in the name of the best intention and only the positivity that comes from precision in decision will help us all in the West move forward. 
 


Some examples  

Dr. Phil Just Risked It All With a Surprising Speech in Support of Donald Trump

He basically just called the Democratic Party a bunch of bullies because they ruin people's careers and shame them to oblivion if they dare support Donald Trump. Now, he's giving the bully party a big middle finger and throwing his support for Trump. “I'm not here just to stand up for Donald J. Trump. Lord knows he doesn't need me to stand up for him. He's tough as an old army boot. He's got lots of enemies, different groups that are scared. And between them, they have impeached him, indicted him, raided him, railroaded him, shot him, and sued him. And where is he? He is still standing. He just keeps on because he loves this country, too.”

Saturday, October 26, 2024

Something very empty and reactionary in the Labor leadership ?

 Queensland election 26th October 2024

Steven Miles didn't win but he still makes out his free lunch idea will create a great leap forward in education. Sure works a treat sometimes with some people. Daniel Andrews will always be fighting the image of his term as fear driven and his contribution as more about ruling by law rather than by education, Respect for me and what I know and not the minds of them who voted to trust me. 
What is going on inside their heads "I don't trust you cause , perhaps I don't trust myself? "

How can anyone trust those who condemn and attack another leaders character , unless they have 
nothing else to say . Miles ( like Bowen ) tries to talk empty budget in the opposition but the emptiness was closer to home. Miles couldn't bring himself to honor achievement ( past ) and made the pathetic attempt to tick something unfulfilled , unframed and full of mystery of his own that he says he WOULD HAVE done in the future.

How can a leader whose going out , not focus on substance ( of his term and by all parties) unless he is unsure of that substance.


Nietzsche said the danger of all dangers is that the herd mentality of those who cannot bring themselves to say what success is, will continue to pull down those who do.

Wednesday, May 08, 2024

If not Economics , certainly Ecology

 This post is inspired by  A press Club discussion headed by Colin Barnett and Saul Eslake. Well done to both of them and Laura and The Press Club  for hosting .


Their thoughtful recommendations to set GST transfers in some sort of concrete appears very grounded.

Especially when you look at the idiotic hoop jumping most small taxpayers and empires of bureaus create. If young people are to contribute to this great country, they must not think their houses are the key to prosperity as we seem to. 
Saul's gibes (banning timber harvesting )  and Colins counter jibe (no pokies in WA) aside,  the  issue of funding  health and  education need the independence ( to create true resilience education instead of half baked education at our bereft universities )   

The key point is , while both the guests know a lot about economic realities and prosperity and in Colins case ---real empire building ambitions  few sitting in seats have any idea how to make all the Talk of the BIGGER PICTURE in ECOLOGY  happen.

It's about real risk  EDUCATION and not the token and guilt ridden obfuscation (and fear of complex natural forces)  of the media simples stories. 


ECONOMISTS  don't know everything  and cooperation and risk taking without too much government education and science in practice ( with ALL environment  questions ) is the key-----ECOLOGY 

Why no thinking Australian should support the minorities who currently control the agendas . 



While the ignorant and arrogant Greens and wannabes control our electoral system, our politicians will talk to their childish halfbaked rubbish and spend money to try and control things like hot air. 



Sunday, October 15, 2023

Who is the idiot here ? The city or the country? The progressives or the practical ?

Are the people of Australia really racist ?  I would say with Jacinta clearly not , but others will keep wondering  The real people  have just rejected  letting any one culture ,voice or race  have an unequal voice and they were right to do so . Why progressives let themsleves be conned by 65000 years of history is clear -- they didn't study it or culture properly but relied on some shallow form of naturally led blessing .
The future is with science and sound practice informed by culture , not the other way around.  

Last night the people rejected a man who thought he was doing the right thing to honor a wonderful woman who was doing the right thing .
Lets hope this woman continues to inspire us and the world and resist the nonsense of good intentions  being forced into our already overloaded listening system.  
As Jacinta said , This is indeed a great country and we as a people are pleased that our democracy is practically supportive ( and not theoretical) of an equal voice for all .

 I hope free people everywhere  will rejoice with us . 

Progressives will take a while to absorb the referendum result . They need to look closely at why their faith in culturally constructed truths is really moribund and inadequate for our kids future . 

They may never realize the fact that the elites insisted on a change in the listening system which was a result of them NOT listening and a faith in the mythical magic idea of change in laws to make men better . This last attitude was for a time in Western history left in the dark past and hopefully will go back there.
The changes proposed by the government were as shallow as shit and the people rejected them . 

The boy used words "we ,they "+ made it all sound like what he decided was about the will+generosity of the people. But really, it was all about him. Legacy of just another man who can't see how he justifies great evil in the name of the best intention.

Saturday, October 14, 2023

DOMESTIC VIOLENCE , and its causes goes unreported on OUR ABC

 Presumably because it's not PC to say so ........ even on the ABC   (see in particular the claims of Jacinta Price and those who have observed major causal elements inside aboriginal communities where traditional culture is observed -- as far back as 1880; see below ) 

DOMESTIC VIOLENCE  goes UNREPORTED  and totally MISUNDERSTOOD 

Today is the day of the referendum and "progressives' all around the country cannot believe that their fellow Australians can be so racist ( or at least appear to be )
This false perception goes to the heart of the angst and blind sidedness of our generation . Progressives, having largely proven to prove nothing, are not sure about our culture,  but we switch channels and say  we think 60000 years might have taught the first people's something .

Fair enough , but to vote for a constitutional change means our forebears got something wrong  which is where our ABC could have been helpful..
Not everything is wrong .
Where was the constitution wrong? No.  It seems to me the clause removed in 67 was a neccesary adjustment and the idea of institutional 'non recognition"  was a misunderstanding and   a category error. not a helpful one but one that simply happens as Boswick found , becuase you can't actually locate all the aboriginal people and the decision had been made to try ( right or not) to protect them .( before even 1850 when only handfuls of europeans set up little towns like Colac Warnambool and Port Fairy  ( Boswick's most detailed account of numbers , agriculture,  and conflict in 1857. My impression from Boswicks very comapssionate reporting is that just then ,as now, we steel and wheel merchants didn't really know how to help the first peoples, who were just overwhelmed by the cultural differences .   

So this lie has become a bigger one in the hands of those who want more power and opportunity to promote their own righteousness. Sure there is hurt injustice and plain takeover but what human community is free of those injustices ,even from our own ? I can make a list only 3 recent generations long . Are we ever going to forgive as we have been taught to do for our own good, even though we can't always forget ?????
Like children, the country follows the child Whitlam,  Andrews, Turnbull and Albo into solving a problem that wasn't there but was an action, maybe m  built on a mix of real care and also despair and some guilt.( still not OUR guilt as some post or pre Christians would have it !!!!) 
All that doesn't mean the children presume to have answers, and that the quick fix of a bit of law and statute (constitutional) is really going to help things.

The West's best answer to injustice heaped upon one has always been counterintuitive ( not revengeful as our bodies tempt us ): Overcome evil with good. 



  . 

If we ever do rewrite the constitution , which might not be a bad thing. 
we could do what Washington and others did and said in the USA
"Under God we are all equal and in this land it is incumbent on the government to prove it so before the law . "
We wouldn't be , as Albo the god like master of ceremonies TODAY be singling out one race for special privileges and him for special note as Pa. 
A real progress historian scientist  would go sifting the good from the bad ; the sustainable from the unsustainable . no such attempt by our publicly funded truth seeking journos . That is bad .

 

  1. The ABC could have asked or just reported Bonwick  - yes the first peoples were counted even in 1857 
Next question 

  1. Can we learn anything about land use . yes we can and yes we can be very critical of industarail methods and eco thinking which was wrong for land use here .Bruce Pascoe and Bill Gammage  butchered the prospects of a proper scinetific review - still needed .
No we must support ALL cultures as Niebuhr called for it ----- to be subject to revision , The closer scrutiny not just of time, but genuine independant scientific , philosophic and historical scrutiny  - sustainability 
  1. Were the first peoples harsh in their treatment of each other and were they stuck? 
    like some moderns  whose in faith in Nature , which in the dark of the days night gave them, as it does now us , as excuse to be brutal ( read White again on children and mothers ) 

The ABC 's failure to properly follow up on Jacintas Price's point that if The VOICE of some tribes is listened to, the domestic violence on remote women and children can be expected to increase.  ( read J,. Smiths  account  of  Booandik Tribe 1880 ) 

note  her detailed descriptions of aboriginal marriage practice and the common suicide of mothers and killing of babies
. pages 4-7
If culture is worshiped again then cruel nature will again rule because men will use it as a licence . 

Time for the ABC to properly and fiercely study how domestic violence can be so easily prosecuted by men who get their own way with women --  Add this to an honest account of the history of modern west and their menfolk as well
. 

The West's best answer to injustice heaped upon one has always been counterintuitive ( not revengeful as our bodies tempt us): Overcome evil with good. 



 Apart from the intro and this ending, this note was posted before the result was known (extra note made 8pm 14th Oct)  

Aside added 28th Oct 2023

While the beaten wife may not get a technical quick fix to domestic violence by the above complex truth ,( overcoming evil with good )  (that is by SIMPLY allowing her partner to beat her --thats not a thoughtful response to a man ouuta control)  we all have to bear in marriage and family the assaults and insults from our partners who don't always understand or agree with us .It makes us all angry from time to time and IMO we must all face the complex truth about anger being both helpful AND dangerous.  

As Western law and culture clearly indicates if you are going to PREVENT and TREAT violence ( and deal with anger for example -  an adrenalin response?)  you have to accept that VERBAL ASSAULT is as bad as PHYSICAL assault . Sometime I know as someone who has worked with unhappy alcoholics,  that the only preventative defence you often have  is to run away . Noradrenaline too works that way  by allowing time , distance and some return to reason to play  their part.in the face of the wild emotional dangers from anger and adrenalin  

Unreliable POSITION and NEWS reporting IS WORSE THAN PARTY POLITICS .

Our ABC used to be good at lots of things .
Its now at its worst in areas where it thinks it is good at ; where self righteousness has taken over  from thorough examination.  Where it thinks its doing science but its doing no such thing.
The windows are closed on so many areas " ABC is closing comments on this item ' is all over their Netspace and is very indicative . They identify fear so often but allow the fearless to be broadcast too seldom . Such re 

Areas where ABC esp ABCTV  now fails badly
NEWS
There are a few of my old friends clinging to the ship, but not many. The mood is one of " we really don't know wwho to trust anymore ". The trouble is the ABC know how how to be nice and have the budget to fact check and remodel the background at a moments notice . What's missing is the unpredictable world outside the closet
Limpets are gradually dropping off and there is no glue or incentive to bring them back.
The glue of respect for really listening that we treasured  in early 3LO presenters has largely gone .   
The time when the ABC just reported what happened and what the participants and observers said has long gone too.
Reporters add adjectives and commentary so when you listen you never quite know WHO you are listening too .
The Eldership at the ABC is, like the peer review of their practical non-science, missing  .
It should ALL be culled .
Time the public knew that our ABC have been run for decades by inexperienced  reactionaries  who should have passed the baton on to someone who has some real knowledge, confession and experience.
Phillip Adams being in hiding for years, but unlike the others,  is so thick skinned he thinks he has something to add to his never ending opening and closing of doors on VOICES. 
The ABC has cultivated the sickening greeting on departure " Moving on: they say when the guest starts telling us something new" .  
The Australian by contrast makes a good read -- this weekend. 
 

Friday, October 06, 2023

The proposed changes to the Australian constitution ( THE VOICE ) on October 14th will fail

 For lots of reasons which show in particular that you cannot get agreement without telling those who sign up exactly what they are committing to. Only a wooly-headed leader could allow the committee to get what it wanted without taking it to the public - What should have happened is like happened to the 30 pager in 1901 with years of consultation over ' the words " .

A bigger rat has never been sighted.
The biggest surprise on the week B4 is the Yes campaign's revelation of their poor understanding of how people think and how to treat their minds and hearts with respect. 
This is what ALBO did today 6th October when he carelessly dismissed the right of religious ( esp Christian) group members to not agree with their leaders,
This is not a dictatorship yet. 
If only the Church and State could control those pesky rebels known as Jesus people .2000 years of history of a radicalism that,while somewhat predictable in some ways ,  is far less predictable politically and much more fearless than any power broker could imagine if there is conflict between what the books say and any Institution says.  

Our Prime Minister and the media made a totally false and foolish claim today. They said " all churches"  support the VOICE changes to the Constitution. Neither a church or a State can dictate what a believer believes.  

Read this State cancelled radio broadcast made in 1933 ( 6 years before WW 2 started )

https://www.stmichaelsarlington.org/uploads/files/1933-radio-addressdocx_142.pdf





The paradox for a believer is that all this unbeliever focus on more power and more voice  ignores the reality that man's power is always limited ( even a tyrant 0 and is dependent on God letting such persons have it for a while , Far more powerful to let your VOICE be heard by your Saviour and Creator and Redeemer .